# Buyback Event creative for car dealerships

> A buyback campaign makes one offer: the store will buy the customer's vehicle for more than they'd expect, and help them into the next one. The strongest versions read like a personal message from the sales manager — a printed email with a pen-signed note, or a handwritten card — and name the customer's own vehicle. It's also the engine inside many of Xcel's holiday campaigns.

Source: https://xcelmediagroup.com/creative/buyback-event · By Xcel Media Group · Updated Oct 13, 2026

## Key facts

- **Type:** Evergreen
- **When it runs:** Any month of the year
- **Book by:** 28 days before you want it in-home
- **Channels:** Postcard, Letter, Email, Facebook, SMS
- **Formats:** Postcard, Printed email, Handwritten note
- **Results (Jan 1 – Oct 12, 2026):** 50 campaigns at 36 dealerships, 337,832 pieces mailed, 1,316 DMS-matched sold units, 8,408 repair orders

## The creative, channel by channel

### Postcard

A first-class buyback postcard: the store's inventory on the front; on the back, a signed note from the dealer offering to buy the owner's own year and model, with a deadline, a tracked number, a personal PIN and a text-me QR code. New Motors Subaru's run of this piece matched 101 sold units and 1,257 repair orders from 5,000 cards.

- Image (Postcard front): https://xcelmediagroup.com/creative/buyback-event/postcard-front.jpg
- Image (Postcard back): https://xcelmediagroup.com/creative/buyback-event/postcard-back.jpg
- PDF: https://xcelmediagroup.com/creative/pdf/buyback-event-postcard.pdf

### Letter

The two formats that read as personal mail, not an ad: the sales manager's email printed on letterhead with a pen-signed Post-it, and a handwritten note card. The printed email is the piece behind Airport Kia of Naples' 697 responses from 10,000 letters.

- Image (Printed email front): https://xcelmediagroup.com/creative/buyback-event/letter-printed-email.jpg
- Image (Handwritten note front): https://xcelmediagroup.com/creative/buyback-event/letter-handwritten-note.jpg
- PDF (Printed email): https://xcelmediagroup.com/creative/pdf/buyback-event-letter-printed-email.pdf

### Email

Sent the day the mail lands to in-market shoppers around the store: the trade-in offer up top, a one-tap "Value your trade" button, and the buyback ask — "We will buy your car!" — closing it out. This is a real Xcel send for Lehighton Kia.

- Image (Email): https://xcelmediagroup.com/creative/buyback-event/email.jpg
- Subject line: "Fall Into Savings: Get More for Your Trade This Season"
- Real send for Lehighton Kia, Nov 18, 2025: 100,000 sent, 14,937 opens (14.9%), 2,199 clicks (2.2%)
- Where the clicks went: New vehicles in the email 604; Home page 464; Contact us & directions 237; Service & service specials 227; Get pre-approved 223; Sell us your car 204; Value your trade 204; Used inventory 36

### Facebook

A VIP trade-in bonus voucher in the feed from the day the mail lands to the deadline, shown to the mailed households and look-alike shoppers nearby. The voucher gives the store a reason to ask for the sales manager by name.

- Image (Facebook): https://xcelmediagroup.com/creative/buyback-event/facebook.jpg

### SMS

A short text from a real person at the store to customers who've opted in, three to five days after the mail lands — the nudge that turns "I got your letter" into an appointment.

- Sample thread (fictional store and customer):
  - Store: Hi Marcus, it's Dan at Demo Motors. We'd like to buy your 2019 Silverado — the offer in the letter we sent is good through Saturday. Want me to put real numbers together? Reply STOP to opt out
  - Customer: Sure, what's it worth?
  - Store: I'll have the appraisal ready — does 11am Saturday work? Takes about 20 minutes, and you're under no obligation.

## How it performed in 2026

Xcel campaigns named as buyback, in-home Jan 1 – Oct 12, 2026. Sold units and repair orders are households on the mailed list matched in each store's DMS within the campaign's attribution window — 43 of the 50 campaigns ran at stores with a DMS feed.

| Dealership | In-home | Piece | Mailed | Responded | Sold | ROs |
|---|---|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| New Motors Subaru | Jun 2026 | First-class buyback postcard | 5,000 | 19 | 101 | 1,257 |
| Airport Kia of Naples | Jul 2026 | Pen-signed printed email | 10,000 | 697 | 92 | 520 |
| Bev Smith Kia | May 2026 | Pen-signed printed email | 10,000 | 769 | 64 | — |

## Why it works

Every owner wonders what their vehicle is worth. A buyback piece answers with a specific, personal offer from a named person at the store, which lands harder than a generic "top dollar for trades" line:

- **It names their vehicle**, pulled from your DMS, so the offer is obviously meant for them.
- **It comes from a person**, not a brand — a sales manager's printed email with a pen-signed Post-it, or a [handwritten note](https://xcelmediagroup.com/direct-mail/handwritten).
- **It sets a deadline** the store will honor, which is what turns curiosity into an appointment.
- **It feeds the used lot and the showroom at once** — the trade comes in and the customer drives out in something newer.

## Who gets it

Owners whose vehicles the store wants and who are likely in an equity position — past buyers and service customers from your own records, matched to what's moving on the used lot ([database & equity mail](https://xcelmediagroup.com/direct-mail/database)). Recent buyers are suppressed. Half of the 2026 runs added text follow-up to customers who had opted in.

## One concept, every season

Because the offer doesn't depend on the calendar, buyback is the campaign most often dressed up for a holiday. In the last year Xcel ran it as a W-2 / tax-season buyback, a Memorial Day buyback letter, a Black Friday Buy Back Event and a holiday greeting card with a buyback offer inside. The creative changes; the mechanics — a named vehicle, a premium offer, a real deadline — stay the same. See the [marketing calendar](https://xcelmediagroup.com/creative/calendar) for where it fits.

## How the channels work together

Mail carries the offer because it's addressed to a household and names the vehicle. The day it lands, [email](https://xcelmediagroup.com/email) and a [Facebook](https://xcelmediagroup.com/facebook) trade-in bonus ad put the same offer in front of in-market shoppers around the store, and a few days later [texts](https://xcelmediagroup.com/sms) go to customers who have opted in. Every call, text and scan is tracked in [UpDash](https://xcelmediagroup.com/updash/tracking). Afterwards the full mailed list is matched against the DMS — one VIN, one date, every deal counted once — which is where the results above come from.

## Schedule

- **4 weeks out**: Campaign booked: the offer, the deadline and the vehicles the used lot wants are set, and the creative is approved.
- **2 weeks out** (letter): List pulled from the DMS — owners in likely equity, recent buyers suppressed.
- **10 days out** (postcard): Each piece personalized with the owner and their vehicle, and sent to print.
- **In-home** (letter): The buyback postcard, the sales manager's printed email or the handwritten note lands.
- **Same day** (email): Email to the store's list with a one-tap trade valuation; the Facebook trade-in bonus ad starts and runs through the deadline.
- **3 – 5 days after** (sms): Text follow-up to opted-in customers; replies worked by the store's team.
- **30 / 60 / 90 days**: UpDash matches the mailed list to DMS sales and service.

## Frequently asked questions

### What is a dealership buyback campaign?

A campaign that offers to buy a customer's current vehicle — named on the piece from the dealership's records — at a premium, usually with help getting into a newer one. It's mailed to the store's own customers and often followed up by text.

### Does a buyback campaign actually sell cars, or just buy them?

Both. The offer is to buy the vehicle, but most customers who sell still need a replacement. The 2026 numbers above are DMS-matched sold units and repair orders from the mailed households.

### What makes a buyback mailer work?

Specifics: the customer's own vehicle, a named person at the store, a deadline the store will honor, and a format that reads as personal — a printed email with a pen-signed note, or a handwritten card — rather than an ad.

### Can a buyback campaign run during a holiday?

Yes — it's the most common holiday wrapper. Xcel has run it as a tax-season buyback, a Memorial Day buyback letter, a Black Friday Buy Back Event and a holiday greeting card. The mechanics stay the same; the creative and deadline change.

---

Browse every campaign: https://xcelmediagroup.com/creative · Marketing calendar: https://xcelmediagroup.com/creative/calendar · Talk to Xcel: https://xcelmediagroup.com/demo
